Skip to content

Navigating the Complexities of the Florida Baker Act: Insights from Attorney Justin Drach

Florida has witnessed a surge in Baker Act cases in recent years, with over 210,000 incidents reported, including 37,000 involving children. These numbers underscore the urgency for individuals, especially parents, to understand their rights under the Baker Act fully. 

“The Florida Mental Health Act” more commonly known as the “The Baker Act”, can be overwhelming, especially during emotional or emergency situations where quick decisions are crucial. It is vital to understand your rights and navigate these challenging circumstances effectively. Justin Drach, an attorney specializing in Baker Act cases, is here to guide you through the intricacies of this critical Florida statute. His legal expertise, combined with his role at Thoele Drach, positions him uniquely to offer comprehensive insights into this often-misunderstood law. 

Understanding the Baker Act

The Baker Act enables individuals who meet certain criteria to receive emergency mental health services and temporary detention for evaluation and stabilization. However, many individuals and their families are unaware of their rights and what to expect during the process. 

One of the most common misconceptions about the Baker Act is the 72-hour hold period. Contrary to popular belief, this period is not a blanket authorization to detain someone. Instead, within these 72 hours, facilities must either release the patient, arrange for voluntary outpatient treatment, obtain consent for voluntary inpatient treatment, or file for further involuntary placement. Understanding these options and the implications of voluntary admission, which often bypasses the court’s scrutiny, is vital. 

Protecting Patient Rights

Facilities sometimes fail to inform patients or their families about filed petitions, using “HIPAA” as an excuse. This lack of transparency is concerning and warrants questioning. Moreover, the Baker Act emphasizes that confinement should be avoided if support from family or friends can prevent harm, particularly in cases involving children. 

As an attorney, Justin Drach has observed numerous instances where facilities restrict legal access, hindering the patient’s ability to seek justice. Florida Statute 394.467 mandates the right of an attorney to access patients, witnesses, and relevant records, a critical aspect in representing the patient’s interests. 

Identifying and Challenging Fraudulent Practices

Recognizing signs of misconduct in Baker Act proceedings is crucial. These include denying attorney access, restricting family communication, failing to provide informed consent, and pressuring patients during intake. Additionally, the duration of treatment should never be dictated by insurance coverage. 

A facility’s reluctance to discuss habeas corpus rights, reliance on paper records that can be falsified or changed, and difficulties accessing medical records or reaching clients are significant red flags. 

Empowering Yourself with Knowledge

Understanding your rights under the Baker Act is essential. If you suspect violations or feel something isn’t right, trust your instincts and seek legal counsel. Thoele Drach is a valuable resource in these situations. They provide extensive online materials and are ready to assist you in protecting your or your loved ones’ rights. 


Navigating the complexities of the Baker Act need not be an insurmountable hurdle. You can navigate these challenges effectively by educating yourself and seeking expert legal advice when needed. Remember, your rights are paramount, and understanding them is the first step toward ensuring your protection. 

For more information, guidance, or legal support regarding the Florida Baker Act, visit Thoele Drach’s website or contact them directly. Justin Drach, attorney at Thoele Drach, specializing in Baker Act cases, will gladly guide you through the process and protect your rights.

Get Immediate Help Call Now